Happy but not Clappy : WorshipSongs in a Catholic Context
"It was happy but not clappy." So said a retired priest who recently attended one of our monthly 'New Fire' Masses, where we aim to combine the Charismatic and the Catholic, the Traditional and the Contemporary. The comment was, I believe, intended to be complimentary! The term 'Happy-Clappy' is, of course, often used in a quite derogatory sense, usually by traditionalists to describe modern Evangelical or Evangelical-Charismatic worship. I must confess that I have often used the phrase in this context in the past to express varying degrees of disapproval and even disdain. As a classically trained musician and a committed Anglo-Catholic, for many years I poured scorn on all such worship which I saw as being at best banal and at worst positively infantile. Whilst I remain unapologetic in my criticism of any worship that is liturgically illiterate or simply 'dumbed-down' to the lowest common denominator, a broadening (or should that be 'cathol...